The Pink Letter

Theon is most likely the author of the Pink Letter. Others have already made videos regarding for and against arguments for others, but to my knowledge no one has yet suggested Theon. And yet he is the best possible suspect. I won’t go over the positive or negatives of any other suspect. This is strictly about Theon.

game-of-thrones-theon.jpg

He has the run of Winterfell, even showing Lady Dustin the crypts.

barbrey_dustin_by_eluas-da6z2l9.jpg
winterfell.jpg

One can safely assume he has access to the rookery.

Maester_Murenmure.jpg

He knows Ramsey better than anyone. Better even than Roose, I suspect. Nobody would know better than Theon how he talks, or his obsession with being called a bastard.

thX5E9HBF3.jpg

He also knows how much Jon hates being called a bastard.

bastardjon.jpg

He met and talked to Mance and his spearwives

Mance_Rayder_in_The_Children.jpg
SmallHero_ASOIF-Sperwives.jpg

It’s true we don’t know the full extent of their conversation, but we do have hints that Mance told him some things. And he doesn’t know that Jon sent Mance’s son away.

He would also have heard about Melisandre while also being ignorant of her actual location.

300px-Melisandre_GOT.jpg

Theon would not have been able to obtain any skin, so he couldn’t have copied Ramsey on this point.

cache_34237930.jpg
house_bolton_by_thasiloron-d8xi4dr.png

He wouldn’t have had access to the Bolton seal either.

He, of course, knows better than anyone that Ramsey refers to him as ‘Reek’.

250px-Heke_TheMico.jpg

And here is the final point, Theon has lost several fingers. This would surely screw with his writing. Thus, his writing might easily have been mistaken for Ramsey’s, who has atrocious handwriting. (The writing used in the background picture is far too legible.)

blViP.jpg

It has long been speculated that Theon is suffering from a split personality. One could easily see him writing the Pink Letter during a disassociated episode.

hoodedman.jpg

Theon also has the strongest motive of all for wanting Jon to come south, to save him. Certainly better than any suggested for Mance. Nor would he be sorry if Jon died in the process.